Full Synopsis
LAKE MANITOC, WISCONSIN- A young girl is talking to her dad and brother before going out swimming in the nearby lake. The girl dives in, but soon gets spooked by something she can't see. Suddenly, something drags her below the water and drowns her.
THE LYNNWOOD INN- Dean is looking at newpaper reports (and the waitress hehe) He shows Sam an article about a girl named Sophie Carlton who drowned in Lake Manitoc. Sam is angry Dean is looking at new cases instead of finding their dad. Dean insists they will find their dad, but there's nothing wrong with killing everything bad along the way. Sam reluctantly agrees.
CARLTON RESIDENCE- Dean and Sam visit the dead girl's dad and brother under the guise of US Wildlife Service officials. (You gotta love the Star Wars reference names 'Ford' and Hammill' that Dean gives) Sophie's brother tells them she was dragged down under the lake and didin't seem to struggle. Sam asks if he can speak to the father, Billy, but he's too distraught.
SHERIFF'S OFFICE- Sam and Dean queation the local sheriff about how many missing persons there have been involving the lake, still under the guise of wildlife officials. Apparently, it's happened a lot, but there are never any bodies. The sheriff says the local dam is leaking anyway, and the lake in question will soon drain as they can't get a grant to fix it. The sheriff's daughter, Andrea appears with her son Lucas, but he won't speak and shy's away from the brothers. The sheriff says he's been through a lot but doesn't elaborate. Dean asks if Andrea can show them to a hotel and she does. He tries flirting with her on the way, but she brushes him off.
HOTEL-Sam looks up drownings on the lake on his laptop and says they've been happening over 35 years but the deaths are getting more frequent. He also finds Lucas' dad was one of the victims and Lucas saw it all happen.
AT THE PARK- Sam and Dean go to see Andrea and Lucas. Dean talks to Lucas and tells him he knows what it's like to lose someone at his age and to actually see it happen. Lucas won't answer back, but draws Dean a picture of a house. Andrea explains he's been silent since his dad died.
CARLTON RESIDENCE- Sophie's dad won't talk to Will his son. Will decides to try and get his dad to eat and goes to prepare/clean some fish. As he's working, the color of the water changes and the sink begins to fill up. Will thinks there is a blockage and sticks his hand it, only to be dragged down until his head is in the water and he drowns.
HOTEL- Sam comes in and tells Dean Will has been drowned in a sink. They conclude what ever is in the water/lake knows the lake is draining and its running out of time to get its revenge. They figure there will be more deaths and that Mr Carlton is somehow involved as he's now lost two children to it.
BY THE LAKE- Sam and Dean go to visit Lucas and after dean tellshim about his mom dying and how he was afraid, but learned to be brave, Lucas gives them a second picture. This time its a house near a white church, and a young boy wearing a cap with a bike.
IN THE CAR- The brothers discuss how Lucas could be drawing things relevant to what's going on. They decide they need to find the house in the new picture, and fast.
WHITE CHURCH- Sam and Dean find the church, and the house in the picture is just across the road. They visit and ask if a little boy lives there with a red bike, and the old woman who answers the door tells them not for 35years. It seems Peter vanished all that time ago and the cops never did find him or a body. Dean spots a photo of Peter with Billy Carlton.
BY THE LAKE- Billy talks to the lake. He says he understands now what he has to do.
IN THE CAR/LAKESIDE- Sam and Dean think Billy killed Peter. They pay him a visit, but he's already taken a boat out on the lake. The brothers shout him to come back, but the boat abruptly explodes.
SHERIFF'S OFFICE- Sam and Dean walk in with the sheriff. Andrea and Lucas are there, and Lucas grabs Dean, obviously upset. The sheriff (her dad) tells Andrea to take Lucas home, and then takes Sam and Dean inside. He tells them he know they're not wildlife officials- he checked and that they could be implicated in Billy's death. He gives them a choice, get arrested or leave town. They agree to leave.
ANDREA'S HOME- Lucas is drawing and Andrea decides to take a bath.
ON THE ROAD- Sam and Dean are in their car when dean turns back to return to town. He's worried about Lucas and doesn't think the case is over somehow.
ANDREA'S HOME- Andrea runs a bath and gets in. She relaxes and closes her eyes, not noticing the running water is turning a strange color. Suddenly, a force drags her below the water. She screams and Lucas pounds on the door unable to get in to help. Luckily, Sam and Dean arrive. Dean kicks the bathroom door in and Sam pulls Andrea from the bath water before she drowns.
NEXT MORNING- Andrea tells Sam she thinks she's going crazy as she heard a voice say 'Come play with me' Sam coonsoles her while Dean goes through some old photo albums. He spots an old school picture of Andrea's dad with Peter. Dean then suggests Andrea's dad was probably involved too, and that's why she was a target. Lucas then goes a little weird and leads them outside toa plot of land. Sam and Dean dig there and find Peter's bike. Andrea's dad appears and holds them at gunpoint. Dean accuses him of helping Billy carlton kill Peter 35 years previously and burying his bike. The sheriff denies it, but Andrea gets him to confess. Dean says they need to destroy Peter's remains, but they can't because Andrea's dad and Billy bullied Peter and accidentally drowned him, letting the body sink in the lake. Dean says they need to get sheriff and everyone away from the lake, but just then they spot Lucas near the water and a ghostly hand pulls him in. Dean and Sam dive in after him but find nothing. Knowing what he must do, Andrea's dad gives himself up to Peter's spirit. Peter drags him under the water and Sam and Dean try to save him to no avail. dean does surface after awhile with Lucas- he looks dead.
IN TOWN- Sam and Dean are by there car and Sam tells Dean 'You can't save everyone.' At this point, you think Lucas died, but just then he runs up with his mum, Andrea. He's talking now and has made the Winchester boys sandwiches for their road trip. Andrea thanks them both for saving Lucas, and Dean learns Lucas the important phrase 'Zepplin Rules!' Then, the Winchester boys ride out of town, rock music playing...
Wed Sep 02, 2009 4:28 pm
